Energy and the Schwarzschild Metric












1












$begingroup$


In the Schwarzschild metric, the geodesic Lagrangian is



$$L=frac{1}{2} left[ left( 1-frac{2m}{r} right) dot{t}^2-frac{dot{r}^2}{1-2m/r}-r^2(dot{theta}^2+sin^2thetadot{psi}^2) right]$$



Therefore the $t$ equation for the geodesic motion of a free particle is



$$frac{d}{dtau}left(frac{partial L}{partial dot{t}}right)=0$$



because the Lagrangian is independent of t. Consequently



$$E=(1-2m/r)dot{t}$$



is constant along the particle worldline.... Suppose that the particle has four-velocity $V$ and unit mass. Then relative to an observer at rest at some point in the particle's history, the particle has speed $v$ given by



$$gamma(v) = frac{1}{sqrt{1-v^2}}=U^aV_a=g_{00}U^0V^0=dot{t}sqrt{1-2m/r}$$



1) How do we get $t$ equation so obviously?



2) How do we get the equation for $E$? There was no justification in my book for this step



3) What is the interpretation of the quantity $U^aV_a$? Is it like a dot product?



4) How do we know that $U^aV_a$ equals $g_{00}U^0V^0$? Where have all the other components of the metric gone?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$

















    1












    $begingroup$


    In the Schwarzschild metric, the geodesic Lagrangian is



    $$L=frac{1}{2} left[ left( 1-frac{2m}{r} right) dot{t}^2-frac{dot{r}^2}{1-2m/r}-r^2(dot{theta}^2+sin^2thetadot{psi}^2) right]$$



    Therefore the $t$ equation for the geodesic motion of a free particle is



    $$frac{d}{dtau}left(frac{partial L}{partial dot{t}}right)=0$$



    because the Lagrangian is independent of t. Consequently



    $$E=(1-2m/r)dot{t}$$



    is constant along the particle worldline.... Suppose that the particle has four-velocity $V$ and unit mass. Then relative to an observer at rest at some point in the particle's history, the particle has speed $v$ given by



    $$gamma(v) = frac{1}{sqrt{1-v^2}}=U^aV_a=g_{00}U^0V^0=dot{t}sqrt{1-2m/r}$$



    1) How do we get $t$ equation so obviously?



    2) How do we get the equation for $E$? There was no justification in my book for this step



    3) What is the interpretation of the quantity $U^aV_a$? Is it like a dot product?



    4) How do we know that $U^aV_a$ equals $g_{00}U^0V^0$? Where have all the other components of the metric gone?










    share|cite|improve this question











    $endgroup$















      1












      1








      1





      $begingroup$


      In the Schwarzschild metric, the geodesic Lagrangian is



      $$L=frac{1}{2} left[ left( 1-frac{2m}{r} right) dot{t}^2-frac{dot{r}^2}{1-2m/r}-r^2(dot{theta}^2+sin^2thetadot{psi}^2) right]$$



      Therefore the $t$ equation for the geodesic motion of a free particle is



      $$frac{d}{dtau}left(frac{partial L}{partial dot{t}}right)=0$$



      because the Lagrangian is independent of t. Consequently



      $$E=(1-2m/r)dot{t}$$



      is constant along the particle worldline.... Suppose that the particle has four-velocity $V$ and unit mass. Then relative to an observer at rest at some point in the particle's history, the particle has speed $v$ given by



      $$gamma(v) = frac{1}{sqrt{1-v^2}}=U^aV_a=g_{00}U^0V^0=dot{t}sqrt{1-2m/r}$$



      1) How do we get $t$ equation so obviously?



      2) How do we get the equation for $E$? There was no justification in my book for this step



      3) What is the interpretation of the quantity $U^aV_a$? Is it like a dot product?



      4) How do we know that $U^aV_a$ equals $g_{00}U^0V^0$? Where have all the other components of the metric gone?










      share|cite|improve this question











      $endgroup$




      In the Schwarzschild metric, the geodesic Lagrangian is



      $$L=frac{1}{2} left[ left( 1-frac{2m}{r} right) dot{t}^2-frac{dot{r}^2}{1-2m/r}-r^2(dot{theta}^2+sin^2thetadot{psi}^2) right]$$



      Therefore the $t$ equation for the geodesic motion of a free particle is



      $$frac{d}{dtau}left(frac{partial L}{partial dot{t}}right)=0$$



      because the Lagrangian is independent of t. Consequently



      $$E=(1-2m/r)dot{t}$$



      is constant along the particle worldline.... Suppose that the particle has four-velocity $V$ and unit mass. Then relative to an observer at rest at some point in the particle's history, the particle has speed $v$ given by



      $$gamma(v) = frac{1}{sqrt{1-v^2}}=U^aV_a=g_{00}U^0V^0=dot{t}sqrt{1-2m/r}$$



      1) How do we get $t$ equation so obviously?



      2) How do we get the equation for $E$? There was no justification in my book for this step



      3) What is the interpretation of the quantity $U^aV_a$? Is it like a dot product?



      4) How do we know that $U^aV_a$ equals $g_{00}U^0V^0$? Where have all the other components of the metric gone?







      differential-geometry mathematical-physics tensors general-relativity






      share|cite|improve this question















      share|cite|improve this question













      share|cite|improve this question




      share|cite|improve this question








      edited Dec 23 '18 at 16:13









      The Pointer

      2,65621639




      2,65621639










      asked Dec 23 '18 at 11:44









      PermianPermian

      2,2781135




      2,2781135






















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          2












          $begingroup$

          The world lines that extremize the proper time between A and B are those which satisfy the Lagrange equation:
          begin{equation}
          -frac{d}{d sigma} left(frac{partial L}{partial({dx^{alpha} / d sigma})} right)+frac{partial L}{partial x^{alpha}}=0
          end{equation}

          Where the Lagrangian is:
          begin{equation}
          L= left(-g_{alpha beta} frac{d x^{alpha}}{d sigma} frac{d x^{beta}}{d sigma} right)^{frac{1}{2}}
          end{equation}

          The Schwarzschild metric in geometrical units is
          begin{equation}
          left(
          begin{array}{cccc}
          -(1-frac{2 m}{r}) & 0 & 0 & 0 \
          0 & (1-frac{2 m}{r})^{-1} & 0 & 0 \
          0 & 0 & r^2 & 0 \
          0 & 0 & 0 & r^2 sin ^2(theta ) \
          end{array}
          right)
          end{equation}

          The parameter t is therefore called world time. If m = 0 the Schwarzschild metric reduces to the Minkowski metric; if $m neq 0$ it is singular for $r = 0$. For r large with respect to m the Schwarzschild metric coincides with the Newtonian approximation, since $2m/r$ is the Newtonian potential outside a spherical body of mass m centered at $r = 0$. In addition, when
          $1−(2m/r)$ vanishes for $r = 2m$, the metric appears to be singular there. This singularity can be removed by choosing a different coordinate system.
          The geodesic equations based on the Schwarzschild metric above are
          begin{equation}
          left(
          begin{array}{ccc}
          frac{d u_0}{d tau} = frac{2 m u_0 u_1}{2 m r-r^2} \
          frac{d u_1}{d tau} = frac{m (2 m-r) u_0^2}{r^3}-frac{m u_1^2}{2 m r-r^2}-(2 m-r) u_2^2-(2 m-r) sin ^2(theta) u_3^2 \
          frac{d u_2}{d tau} = cos (theta) sin (theta ) u_3^2-frac{2 u_1 u_2}{r} \
          frac{d u_3}{d tau} = -frac{2 (u_1+r cot (theta ) u_2) u_3}{r} \
          end{array}
          right)
          end{equation}

          where $u_{alpha}$ are the component of the four proper velocity vector while $tau$ is the proper time. When looking at the metric you can see that is independent of $t$, thus there is a Killing vector associated with this symmetry under displacement of the time coordinate t with components $psi=(1,0,0,0)$. The first equation can be written as:
          begin{equation}
          frac{d}{d tau} left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) = 0
          end{equation}

          which is integrated to give
          begin{equation}
          left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) =- g_{00} frac{dt}{d tau}= E
          end{equation}

          with E constant.
          Now you have to remember that the dot product is obtained by computing the first fundamental form.The first fundamental form is the restriction of the usual dot product in $mathbb{R}^3$ to the tangent plane $T_p S$. Given two vector a and b
          the first fundamental form $Ip (a, b)$ at the point $p$ can be expressed as the bilinear form $a^T g b$, where g is the matrix. In the case of the xy-plane or a cylinder $g$ is a diagonal matrix with diag(g) = (1,1). In this case the dot product of $a$ and $b$ is
          begin{equation}
          (a_1,a_2) left(
          begin{array}{cc}
          1 & 0\
          0 & 1
          end{array}
          right) (b_1,b_2)^T= a_1 b_1+ a_2 b_2
          end{equation}

          However is the matric is not flat we have to account for the terms $g_{alpha, beta}$. So yes, $U^aV_a$ is a dot product, with the index a running from 1 to the 4, since you are in a 4 dimensional space. This dot product can be written as
          begin{equation}
          g_{00} u_0 v_0-g_{00}^{-1} u_1 v_1+r^2 u_2 v_2+ r^2 sin^2(theta)u_3 v_3
          end{equation}

          However, The 4-velocity of a stationary observer is $(u_0,0,0,0)$, so for a stationary observer we have only the term $g_{00} u_0 v_0$.
          Consider now the lapse of proper time τ between two events at a fixed spatial point (differentiation with respect the position is zero) in Schwarzschild space-time:
          begin{equation}
          ds^2=-d tau^2=-g_{00} dt^2
          end{equation}

          hence
          begin{equation}
          d tau=sqrt{g_{00}} dt
          end{equation}

          The element of proper time dτ is measured by a clock at the particular point, while the element of world time dt is fixed for the whole manifold. Since $g_{00}<1$, so $d tau < dt$ i.e. clocks go slower in a gravitational field. In fact time itself goes slower in a gravitational field. In flat spacetime $m$ turn down to zero so that $dt=d tau$, and a clock records the coordinate time $t$.






          share|cite|improve this answer









          $endgroup$














            Your Answer





            StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
            return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
            StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
            StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
            });
            });
            }, "mathjax-editing");

            StackExchange.ready(function() {
            var channelOptions = {
            tags: "".split(" "),
            id: "69"
            };
            initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

            StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
            // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
            if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
            StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
            createEditor();
            });
            }
            else {
            createEditor();
            }
            });

            function createEditor() {
            StackExchange.prepareEditor({
            heartbeatType: 'answer',
            autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
            convertImagesToLinks: true,
            noModals: true,
            showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
            reputationToPostImages: 10,
            bindNavPrevention: true,
            postfix: "",
            imageUploader: {
            brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
            contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
            allowUrls: true
            },
            noCode: true, onDemand: true,
            discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
            ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
            });


            }
            });














            draft saved

            draft discarded


















            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3050280%2fenergy-and-the-schwarzschild-metric%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown

























            1 Answer
            1






            active

            oldest

            votes








            1 Answer
            1






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            2












            $begingroup$

            The world lines that extremize the proper time between A and B are those which satisfy the Lagrange equation:
            begin{equation}
            -frac{d}{d sigma} left(frac{partial L}{partial({dx^{alpha} / d sigma})} right)+frac{partial L}{partial x^{alpha}}=0
            end{equation}

            Where the Lagrangian is:
            begin{equation}
            L= left(-g_{alpha beta} frac{d x^{alpha}}{d sigma} frac{d x^{beta}}{d sigma} right)^{frac{1}{2}}
            end{equation}

            The Schwarzschild metric in geometrical units is
            begin{equation}
            left(
            begin{array}{cccc}
            -(1-frac{2 m}{r}) & 0 & 0 & 0 \
            0 & (1-frac{2 m}{r})^{-1} & 0 & 0 \
            0 & 0 & r^2 & 0 \
            0 & 0 & 0 & r^2 sin ^2(theta ) \
            end{array}
            right)
            end{equation}

            The parameter t is therefore called world time. If m = 0 the Schwarzschild metric reduces to the Minkowski metric; if $m neq 0$ it is singular for $r = 0$. For r large with respect to m the Schwarzschild metric coincides with the Newtonian approximation, since $2m/r$ is the Newtonian potential outside a spherical body of mass m centered at $r = 0$. In addition, when
            $1−(2m/r)$ vanishes for $r = 2m$, the metric appears to be singular there. This singularity can be removed by choosing a different coordinate system.
            The geodesic equations based on the Schwarzschild metric above are
            begin{equation}
            left(
            begin{array}{ccc}
            frac{d u_0}{d tau} = frac{2 m u_0 u_1}{2 m r-r^2} \
            frac{d u_1}{d tau} = frac{m (2 m-r) u_0^2}{r^3}-frac{m u_1^2}{2 m r-r^2}-(2 m-r) u_2^2-(2 m-r) sin ^2(theta) u_3^2 \
            frac{d u_2}{d tau} = cos (theta) sin (theta ) u_3^2-frac{2 u_1 u_2}{r} \
            frac{d u_3}{d tau} = -frac{2 (u_1+r cot (theta ) u_2) u_3}{r} \
            end{array}
            right)
            end{equation}

            where $u_{alpha}$ are the component of the four proper velocity vector while $tau$ is the proper time. When looking at the metric you can see that is independent of $t$, thus there is a Killing vector associated with this symmetry under displacement of the time coordinate t with components $psi=(1,0,0,0)$. The first equation can be written as:
            begin{equation}
            frac{d}{d tau} left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) = 0
            end{equation}

            which is integrated to give
            begin{equation}
            left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) =- g_{00} frac{dt}{d tau}= E
            end{equation}

            with E constant.
            Now you have to remember that the dot product is obtained by computing the first fundamental form.The first fundamental form is the restriction of the usual dot product in $mathbb{R}^3$ to the tangent plane $T_p S$. Given two vector a and b
            the first fundamental form $Ip (a, b)$ at the point $p$ can be expressed as the bilinear form $a^T g b$, where g is the matrix. In the case of the xy-plane or a cylinder $g$ is a diagonal matrix with diag(g) = (1,1). In this case the dot product of $a$ and $b$ is
            begin{equation}
            (a_1,a_2) left(
            begin{array}{cc}
            1 & 0\
            0 & 1
            end{array}
            right) (b_1,b_2)^T= a_1 b_1+ a_2 b_2
            end{equation}

            However is the matric is not flat we have to account for the terms $g_{alpha, beta}$. So yes, $U^aV_a$ is a dot product, with the index a running from 1 to the 4, since you are in a 4 dimensional space. This dot product can be written as
            begin{equation}
            g_{00} u_0 v_0-g_{00}^{-1} u_1 v_1+r^2 u_2 v_2+ r^2 sin^2(theta)u_3 v_3
            end{equation}

            However, The 4-velocity of a stationary observer is $(u_0,0,0,0)$, so for a stationary observer we have only the term $g_{00} u_0 v_0$.
            Consider now the lapse of proper time τ between two events at a fixed spatial point (differentiation with respect the position is zero) in Schwarzschild space-time:
            begin{equation}
            ds^2=-d tau^2=-g_{00} dt^2
            end{equation}

            hence
            begin{equation}
            d tau=sqrt{g_{00}} dt
            end{equation}

            The element of proper time dτ is measured by a clock at the particular point, while the element of world time dt is fixed for the whole manifold. Since $g_{00}<1$, so $d tau < dt$ i.e. clocks go slower in a gravitational field. In fact time itself goes slower in a gravitational field. In flat spacetime $m$ turn down to zero so that $dt=d tau$, and a clock records the coordinate time $t$.






            share|cite|improve this answer









            $endgroup$


















              2












              $begingroup$

              The world lines that extremize the proper time between A and B are those which satisfy the Lagrange equation:
              begin{equation}
              -frac{d}{d sigma} left(frac{partial L}{partial({dx^{alpha} / d sigma})} right)+frac{partial L}{partial x^{alpha}}=0
              end{equation}

              Where the Lagrangian is:
              begin{equation}
              L= left(-g_{alpha beta} frac{d x^{alpha}}{d sigma} frac{d x^{beta}}{d sigma} right)^{frac{1}{2}}
              end{equation}

              The Schwarzschild metric in geometrical units is
              begin{equation}
              left(
              begin{array}{cccc}
              -(1-frac{2 m}{r}) & 0 & 0 & 0 \
              0 & (1-frac{2 m}{r})^{-1} & 0 & 0 \
              0 & 0 & r^2 & 0 \
              0 & 0 & 0 & r^2 sin ^2(theta ) \
              end{array}
              right)
              end{equation}

              The parameter t is therefore called world time. If m = 0 the Schwarzschild metric reduces to the Minkowski metric; if $m neq 0$ it is singular for $r = 0$. For r large with respect to m the Schwarzschild metric coincides with the Newtonian approximation, since $2m/r$ is the Newtonian potential outside a spherical body of mass m centered at $r = 0$. In addition, when
              $1−(2m/r)$ vanishes for $r = 2m$, the metric appears to be singular there. This singularity can be removed by choosing a different coordinate system.
              The geodesic equations based on the Schwarzschild metric above are
              begin{equation}
              left(
              begin{array}{ccc}
              frac{d u_0}{d tau} = frac{2 m u_0 u_1}{2 m r-r^2} \
              frac{d u_1}{d tau} = frac{m (2 m-r) u_0^2}{r^3}-frac{m u_1^2}{2 m r-r^2}-(2 m-r) u_2^2-(2 m-r) sin ^2(theta) u_3^2 \
              frac{d u_2}{d tau} = cos (theta) sin (theta ) u_3^2-frac{2 u_1 u_2}{r} \
              frac{d u_3}{d tau} = -frac{2 (u_1+r cot (theta ) u_2) u_3}{r} \
              end{array}
              right)
              end{equation}

              where $u_{alpha}$ are the component of the four proper velocity vector while $tau$ is the proper time. When looking at the metric you can see that is independent of $t$, thus there is a Killing vector associated with this symmetry under displacement of the time coordinate t with components $psi=(1,0,0,0)$. The first equation can be written as:
              begin{equation}
              frac{d}{d tau} left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) = 0
              end{equation}

              which is integrated to give
              begin{equation}
              left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) =- g_{00} frac{dt}{d tau}= E
              end{equation}

              with E constant.
              Now you have to remember that the dot product is obtained by computing the first fundamental form.The first fundamental form is the restriction of the usual dot product in $mathbb{R}^3$ to the tangent plane $T_p S$. Given two vector a and b
              the first fundamental form $Ip (a, b)$ at the point $p$ can be expressed as the bilinear form $a^T g b$, where g is the matrix. In the case of the xy-plane or a cylinder $g$ is a diagonal matrix with diag(g) = (1,1). In this case the dot product of $a$ and $b$ is
              begin{equation}
              (a_1,a_2) left(
              begin{array}{cc}
              1 & 0\
              0 & 1
              end{array}
              right) (b_1,b_2)^T= a_1 b_1+ a_2 b_2
              end{equation}

              However is the matric is not flat we have to account for the terms $g_{alpha, beta}$. So yes, $U^aV_a$ is a dot product, with the index a running from 1 to the 4, since you are in a 4 dimensional space. This dot product can be written as
              begin{equation}
              g_{00} u_0 v_0-g_{00}^{-1} u_1 v_1+r^2 u_2 v_2+ r^2 sin^2(theta)u_3 v_3
              end{equation}

              However, The 4-velocity of a stationary observer is $(u_0,0,0,0)$, so for a stationary observer we have only the term $g_{00} u_0 v_0$.
              Consider now the lapse of proper time τ between two events at a fixed spatial point (differentiation with respect the position is zero) in Schwarzschild space-time:
              begin{equation}
              ds^2=-d tau^2=-g_{00} dt^2
              end{equation}

              hence
              begin{equation}
              d tau=sqrt{g_{00}} dt
              end{equation}

              The element of proper time dτ is measured by a clock at the particular point, while the element of world time dt is fixed for the whole manifold. Since $g_{00}<1$, so $d tau < dt$ i.e. clocks go slower in a gravitational field. In fact time itself goes slower in a gravitational field. In flat spacetime $m$ turn down to zero so that $dt=d tau$, and a clock records the coordinate time $t$.






              share|cite|improve this answer









              $endgroup$
















                2












                2








                2





                $begingroup$

                The world lines that extremize the proper time between A and B are those which satisfy the Lagrange equation:
                begin{equation}
                -frac{d}{d sigma} left(frac{partial L}{partial({dx^{alpha} / d sigma})} right)+frac{partial L}{partial x^{alpha}}=0
                end{equation}

                Where the Lagrangian is:
                begin{equation}
                L= left(-g_{alpha beta} frac{d x^{alpha}}{d sigma} frac{d x^{beta}}{d sigma} right)^{frac{1}{2}}
                end{equation}

                The Schwarzschild metric in geometrical units is
                begin{equation}
                left(
                begin{array}{cccc}
                -(1-frac{2 m}{r}) & 0 & 0 & 0 \
                0 & (1-frac{2 m}{r})^{-1} & 0 & 0 \
                0 & 0 & r^2 & 0 \
                0 & 0 & 0 & r^2 sin ^2(theta ) \
                end{array}
                right)
                end{equation}

                The parameter t is therefore called world time. If m = 0 the Schwarzschild metric reduces to the Minkowski metric; if $m neq 0$ it is singular for $r = 0$. For r large with respect to m the Schwarzschild metric coincides with the Newtonian approximation, since $2m/r$ is the Newtonian potential outside a spherical body of mass m centered at $r = 0$. In addition, when
                $1−(2m/r)$ vanishes for $r = 2m$, the metric appears to be singular there. This singularity can be removed by choosing a different coordinate system.
                The geodesic equations based on the Schwarzschild metric above are
                begin{equation}
                left(
                begin{array}{ccc}
                frac{d u_0}{d tau} = frac{2 m u_0 u_1}{2 m r-r^2} \
                frac{d u_1}{d tau} = frac{m (2 m-r) u_0^2}{r^3}-frac{m u_1^2}{2 m r-r^2}-(2 m-r) u_2^2-(2 m-r) sin ^2(theta) u_3^2 \
                frac{d u_2}{d tau} = cos (theta) sin (theta ) u_3^2-frac{2 u_1 u_2}{r} \
                frac{d u_3}{d tau} = -frac{2 (u_1+r cot (theta ) u_2) u_3}{r} \
                end{array}
                right)
                end{equation}

                where $u_{alpha}$ are the component of the four proper velocity vector while $tau$ is the proper time. When looking at the metric you can see that is independent of $t$, thus there is a Killing vector associated with this symmetry under displacement of the time coordinate t with components $psi=(1,0,0,0)$. The first equation can be written as:
                begin{equation}
                frac{d}{d tau} left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) = 0
                end{equation}

                which is integrated to give
                begin{equation}
                left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) =- g_{00} frac{dt}{d tau}= E
                end{equation}

                with E constant.
                Now you have to remember that the dot product is obtained by computing the first fundamental form.The first fundamental form is the restriction of the usual dot product in $mathbb{R}^3$ to the tangent plane $T_p S$. Given two vector a and b
                the first fundamental form $Ip (a, b)$ at the point $p$ can be expressed as the bilinear form $a^T g b$, where g is the matrix. In the case of the xy-plane or a cylinder $g$ is a diagonal matrix with diag(g) = (1,1). In this case the dot product of $a$ and $b$ is
                begin{equation}
                (a_1,a_2) left(
                begin{array}{cc}
                1 & 0\
                0 & 1
                end{array}
                right) (b_1,b_2)^T= a_1 b_1+ a_2 b_2
                end{equation}

                However is the matric is not flat we have to account for the terms $g_{alpha, beta}$. So yes, $U^aV_a$ is a dot product, with the index a running from 1 to the 4, since you are in a 4 dimensional space. This dot product can be written as
                begin{equation}
                g_{00} u_0 v_0-g_{00}^{-1} u_1 v_1+r^2 u_2 v_2+ r^2 sin^2(theta)u_3 v_3
                end{equation}

                However, The 4-velocity of a stationary observer is $(u_0,0,0,0)$, so for a stationary observer we have only the term $g_{00} u_0 v_0$.
                Consider now the lapse of proper time τ between two events at a fixed spatial point (differentiation with respect the position is zero) in Schwarzschild space-time:
                begin{equation}
                ds^2=-d tau^2=-g_{00} dt^2
                end{equation}

                hence
                begin{equation}
                d tau=sqrt{g_{00}} dt
                end{equation}

                The element of proper time dτ is measured by a clock at the particular point, while the element of world time dt is fixed for the whole manifold. Since $g_{00}<1$, so $d tau < dt$ i.e. clocks go slower in a gravitational field. In fact time itself goes slower in a gravitational field. In flat spacetime $m$ turn down to zero so that $dt=d tau$, and a clock records the coordinate time $t$.






                share|cite|improve this answer









                $endgroup$



                The world lines that extremize the proper time between A and B are those which satisfy the Lagrange equation:
                begin{equation}
                -frac{d}{d sigma} left(frac{partial L}{partial({dx^{alpha} / d sigma})} right)+frac{partial L}{partial x^{alpha}}=0
                end{equation}

                Where the Lagrangian is:
                begin{equation}
                L= left(-g_{alpha beta} frac{d x^{alpha}}{d sigma} frac{d x^{beta}}{d sigma} right)^{frac{1}{2}}
                end{equation}

                The Schwarzschild metric in geometrical units is
                begin{equation}
                left(
                begin{array}{cccc}
                -(1-frac{2 m}{r}) & 0 & 0 & 0 \
                0 & (1-frac{2 m}{r})^{-1} & 0 & 0 \
                0 & 0 & r^2 & 0 \
                0 & 0 & 0 & r^2 sin ^2(theta ) \
                end{array}
                right)
                end{equation}

                The parameter t is therefore called world time. If m = 0 the Schwarzschild metric reduces to the Minkowski metric; if $m neq 0$ it is singular for $r = 0$. For r large with respect to m the Schwarzschild metric coincides with the Newtonian approximation, since $2m/r$ is the Newtonian potential outside a spherical body of mass m centered at $r = 0$. In addition, when
                $1−(2m/r)$ vanishes for $r = 2m$, the metric appears to be singular there. This singularity can be removed by choosing a different coordinate system.
                The geodesic equations based on the Schwarzschild metric above are
                begin{equation}
                left(
                begin{array}{ccc}
                frac{d u_0}{d tau} = frac{2 m u_0 u_1}{2 m r-r^2} \
                frac{d u_1}{d tau} = frac{m (2 m-r) u_0^2}{r^3}-frac{m u_1^2}{2 m r-r^2}-(2 m-r) u_2^2-(2 m-r) sin ^2(theta) u_3^2 \
                frac{d u_2}{d tau} = cos (theta) sin (theta ) u_3^2-frac{2 u_1 u_2}{r} \
                frac{d u_3}{d tau} = -frac{2 (u_1+r cot (theta ) u_2) u_3}{r} \
                end{array}
                right)
                end{equation}

                where $u_{alpha}$ are the component of the four proper velocity vector while $tau$ is the proper time. When looking at the metric you can see that is independent of $t$, thus there is a Killing vector associated with this symmetry under displacement of the time coordinate t with components $psi=(1,0,0,0)$. The first equation can be written as:
                begin{equation}
                frac{d}{d tau} left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) = 0
                end{equation}

                which is integrated to give
                begin{equation}
                left((1-frac{2 m}{r}) u_0(tau) right) =- g_{00} frac{dt}{d tau}= E
                end{equation}

                with E constant.
                Now you have to remember that the dot product is obtained by computing the first fundamental form.The first fundamental form is the restriction of the usual dot product in $mathbb{R}^3$ to the tangent plane $T_p S$. Given two vector a and b
                the first fundamental form $Ip (a, b)$ at the point $p$ can be expressed as the bilinear form $a^T g b$, where g is the matrix. In the case of the xy-plane or a cylinder $g$ is a diagonal matrix with diag(g) = (1,1). In this case the dot product of $a$ and $b$ is
                begin{equation}
                (a_1,a_2) left(
                begin{array}{cc}
                1 & 0\
                0 & 1
                end{array}
                right) (b_1,b_2)^T= a_1 b_1+ a_2 b_2
                end{equation}

                However is the matric is not flat we have to account for the terms $g_{alpha, beta}$. So yes, $U^aV_a$ is a dot product, with the index a running from 1 to the 4, since you are in a 4 dimensional space. This dot product can be written as
                begin{equation}
                g_{00} u_0 v_0-g_{00}^{-1} u_1 v_1+r^2 u_2 v_2+ r^2 sin^2(theta)u_3 v_3
                end{equation}

                However, The 4-velocity of a stationary observer is $(u_0,0,0,0)$, so for a stationary observer we have only the term $g_{00} u_0 v_0$.
                Consider now the lapse of proper time τ between two events at a fixed spatial point (differentiation with respect the position is zero) in Schwarzschild space-time:
                begin{equation}
                ds^2=-d tau^2=-g_{00} dt^2
                end{equation}

                hence
                begin{equation}
                d tau=sqrt{g_{00}} dt
                end{equation}

                The element of proper time dτ is measured by a clock at the particular point, while the element of world time dt is fixed for the whole manifold. Since $g_{00}<1$, so $d tau < dt$ i.e. clocks go slower in a gravitational field. In fact time itself goes slower in a gravitational field. In flat spacetime $m$ turn down to zero so that $dt=d tau$, and a clock records the coordinate time $t$.







                share|cite|improve this answer












                share|cite|improve this answer



                share|cite|improve this answer










                answered Dec 26 '18 at 18:32









                UpaxUpax

                1,532613




                1,532613






























                    draft saved

                    draft discarded




















































                    Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!


                    • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                    But avoid



                    • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                    • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


                    Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


                    To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                    draft saved


                    draft discarded














                    StackExchange.ready(
                    function () {
                    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3050280%2fenergy-and-the-schwarzschild-metric%23new-answer', 'question_page');
                    }
                    );

                    Post as a guest















                    Required, but never shown





















































                    Required, but never shown














                    Required, but never shown












                    Required, but never shown







                    Required, but never shown

































                    Required, but never shown














                    Required, but never shown












                    Required, but never shown







                    Required, but never shown







                    Popular posts from this blog

                    Le Mesnil-Réaume

                    Ida-Boy-Ed-Garten

                    web3.py web3.isConnected() returns false always