Bayes network probability question
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
I'm looking at this problem as I review for an exam and I would appreciate it if anyone can give me work/answers to Pr(c), Pr(b), Pr(b,c) and Pr(c,d) so I can check my solutions, and use the work to figure out how I was off if so.
so far i have gotten
Pr(c) = Pr(c|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(c| !a)*Pr(!a) = .48
Pr(b) = Pr(b|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(b| !a)*Pr(!a) = .56
not 100% sure or if these are correct or how to proceed when it comes to the next 2
probability bayesian bayes-theorem bayesian-network
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
I'm looking at this problem as I review for an exam and I would appreciate it if anyone can give me work/answers to Pr(c), Pr(b), Pr(b,c) and Pr(c,d) so I can check my solutions, and use the work to figure out how I was off if so.
so far i have gotten
Pr(c) = Pr(c|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(c| !a)*Pr(!a) = .48
Pr(b) = Pr(b|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(b| !a)*Pr(!a) = .56
not 100% sure or if these are correct or how to proceed when it comes to the next 2
probability bayesian bayes-theorem bayesian-network
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
up vote
-1
down vote
favorite
I'm looking at this problem as I review for an exam and I would appreciate it if anyone can give me work/answers to Pr(c), Pr(b), Pr(b,c) and Pr(c,d) so I can check my solutions, and use the work to figure out how I was off if so.
so far i have gotten
Pr(c) = Pr(c|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(c| !a)*Pr(!a) = .48
Pr(b) = Pr(b|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(b| !a)*Pr(!a) = .56
not 100% sure or if these are correct or how to proceed when it comes to the next 2
probability bayesian bayes-theorem bayesian-network
New contributor
I'm looking at this problem as I review for an exam and I would appreciate it if anyone can give me work/answers to Pr(c), Pr(b), Pr(b,c) and Pr(c,d) so I can check my solutions, and use the work to figure out how I was off if so.
so far i have gotten
Pr(c) = Pr(c|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(c| !a)*Pr(!a) = .48
Pr(b) = Pr(b|a)*Pr(a) + Pr(b| !a)*Pr(!a) = .56
not 100% sure or if these are correct or how to proceed when it comes to the next 2
probability bayesian bayes-theorem bayesian-network
probability bayesian bayes-theorem bayesian-network
New contributor
New contributor
New contributor
asked Nov 16 at 22:16
pog
32
32
New contributor
New contributor
add a comment |
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
What you have done so far for the calculation of $p(b)$ and $p(c)$ is correct:
$$p(c) = p(c|a),p(a) + p(c|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.48$$
$$p(b) = p(b|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.56$$
For the calculation of $p(b,c)$, notice that $$p(b,c)=p(b,c,a)+p(b,c,neg a)=p(b,c|a),p(a)+p(b,c|neg a),p(neg a)$$
Since $b$ and $c$ are independent given $a$ we have that $$p(b,c)=p(b|a),p(c|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(c|neg a),p(neg a)=0.24$$
Finally, we proceed similarly for the calculation of $p(c,d)$. Notice that $$p(c,d)=p(c,d,b) + p(c,d,neg b)$$
We know from before that $p(b,c)=0.24$ and thus $$p(c,d,b)=p(d|b,c),p(b,c)=0.192$$
We can calculate $p(neg b, c)$ the same way we did for $p(b,c)$ (giving also 0.24) and thus $$p(c,d, neg b)=p(d|neg b,c),p(neg b,c)=0.144$$
Therefore, $p(c,d)=0.336$.
- Note: double-check results in calculations.
New contributor
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
What you have done so far for the calculation of $p(b)$ and $p(c)$ is correct:
$$p(c) = p(c|a),p(a) + p(c|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.48$$
$$p(b) = p(b|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.56$$
For the calculation of $p(b,c)$, notice that $$p(b,c)=p(b,c,a)+p(b,c,neg a)=p(b,c|a),p(a)+p(b,c|neg a),p(neg a)$$
Since $b$ and $c$ are independent given $a$ we have that $$p(b,c)=p(b|a),p(c|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(c|neg a),p(neg a)=0.24$$
Finally, we proceed similarly for the calculation of $p(c,d)$. Notice that $$p(c,d)=p(c,d,b) + p(c,d,neg b)$$
We know from before that $p(b,c)=0.24$ and thus $$p(c,d,b)=p(d|b,c),p(b,c)=0.192$$
We can calculate $p(neg b, c)$ the same way we did for $p(b,c)$ (giving also 0.24) and thus $$p(c,d, neg b)=p(d|neg b,c),p(neg b,c)=0.144$$
Therefore, $p(c,d)=0.336$.
- Note: double-check results in calculations.
New contributor
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
What you have done so far for the calculation of $p(b)$ and $p(c)$ is correct:
$$p(c) = p(c|a),p(a) + p(c|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.48$$
$$p(b) = p(b|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.56$$
For the calculation of $p(b,c)$, notice that $$p(b,c)=p(b,c,a)+p(b,c,neg a)=p(b,c|a),p(a)+p(b,c|neg a),p(neg a)$$
Since $b$ and $c$ are independent given $a$ we have that $$p(b,c)=p(b|a),p(c|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(c|neg a),p(neg a)=0.24$$
Finally, we proceed similarly for the calculation of $p(c,d)$. Notice that $$p(c,d)=p(c,d,b) + p(c,d,neg b)$$
We know from before that $p(b,c)=0.24$ and thus $$p(c,d,b)=p(d|b,c),p(b,c)=0.192$$
We can calculate $p(neg b, c)$ the same way we did for $p(b,c)$ (giving also 0.24) and thus $$p(c,d, neg b)=p(d|neg b,c),p(neg b,c)=0.144$$
Therefore, $p(c,d)=0.336$.
- Note: double-check results in calculations.
New contributor
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
up vote
0
down vote
accepted
What you have done so far for the calculation of $p(b)$ and $p(c)$ is correct:
$$p(c) = p(c|a),p(a) + p(c|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.48$$
$$p(b) = p(b|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.56$$
For the calculation of $p(b,c)$, notice that $$p(b,c)=p(b,c,a)+p(b,c,neg a)=p(b,c|a),p(a)+p(b,c|neg a),p(neg a)$$
Since $b$ and $c$ are independent given $a$ we have that $$p(b,c)=p(b|a),p(c|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(c|neg a),p(neg a)=0.24$$
Finally, we proceed similarly for the calculation of $p(c,d)$. Notice that $$p(c,d)=p(c,d,b) + p(c,d,neg b)$$
We know from before that $p(b,c)=0.24$ and thus $$p(c,d,b)=p(d|b,c),p(b,c)=0.192$$
We can calculate $p(neg b, c)$ the same way we did for $p(b,c)$ (giving also 0.24) and thus $$p(c,d, neg b)=p(d|neg b,c),p(neg b,c)=0.144$$
Therefore, $p(c,d)=0.336$.
- Note: double-check results in calculations.
New contributor
What you have done so far for the calculation of $p(b)$ and $p(c)$ is correct:
$$p(c) = p(c|a),p(a) + p(c|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.48$$
$$p(b) = p(b|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(neg a) = 0.56$$
For the calculation of $p(b,c)$, notice that $$p(b,c)=p(b,c,a)+p(b,c,neg a)=p(b,c|a),p(a)+p(b,c|neg a),p(neg a)$$
Since $b$ and $c$ are independent given $a$ we have that $$p(b,c)=p(b|a),p(c|a),p(a) + p(b|neg a),p(c|neg a),p(neg a)=0.24$$
Finally, we proceed similarly for the calculation of $p(c,d)$. Notice that $$p(c,d)=p(c,d,b) + p(c,d,neg b)$$
We know from before that $p(b,c)=0.24$ and thus $$p(c,d,b)=p(d|b,c),p(b,c)=0.192$$
We can calculate $p(neg b, c)$ the same way we did for $p(b,c)$ (giving also 0.24) and thus $$p(c,d, neg b)=p(d|neg b,c),p(neg b,c)=0.144$$
Therefore, $p(c,d)=0.336$.
- Note: double-check results in calculations.
New contributor
New contributor
answered Nov 17 at 0:41
DavidPM
265
265
New contributor
New contributor
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
add a comment |
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
Hi, I understand this up until "We can calculate p(¬b,c) the same way we did for p(b,c) (giving also 0.24)." when I try to do it I get ''P(¬b|a) P(c|a) P(a) + P (¬b |¬a) P(c | ¬a) P (¬a)'' but some things such as P(¬b|a) are not on the diagram so where are you getting those numbers?
– pog
Nov 18 at 17:42
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
$$p(neg b|a)=1-p(b|a)$$. It's the complement.
– DavidPM
Nov 18 at 19:17
add a comment |
pog is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
pog is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
pog is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
pog is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3001701%2fbayes-network-probability-question%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown