Vrftsjtryk

I am taking a calculus course, and in one of the exercises in the book, I am asked to find the limits for both sides of $sqrt{x}$ where $x to 0$.

Graph for sqrt(x) from WolframAlpha:

This is how I solved the exercise:

For simplicity, I choose to disregard the negative result of
$pmsqrt{x}$. Since we are looking at limits for $x to 0$, both
results will converge at the same point, and will thus have the same
limits.

$sqrt{x}$ = $0$ for $x = 0$.

$sqrt{x}$ is a positive real number for all $x > 0$.
$displaystyle lim_{x to 0^+} sqrt{x} = sqrt{+0} = 0$

$sqrt{x}$ is a complex number for all $x < 0$.
$displaystyle lim_{x to 0^-} sqrt{x} = sqrt{-0} = 0 times sqrt{-1} = 0i = 0$

The solution in the book, however, does not agree that there exists a limit for $x to 0-$.

I guess there are three questions in this post, although some of them probably overlaps:

• Does $sqrt{x}$ have a limit for $x to 0$?


• Are square root functions defined to have a range of only real numbers, unless specified otherwise?


• Is $sqrt{x}$ continuous for $-infty < x < infty$?

WolframAlpha says the limit for x=0 is 0: limit (x to 0) sqrt(x)

And also that both the positive and negative limits are 0: limit (x to 0-) sqrt(x)

If my logic is flawed, please correct me.

The answers to your questions depend on whether you are working with $mathbb{R_{geq 0}}$ or $mathbb{R}$ as your domain. $sqrt{x}$ is really not the same function in these two cases.

With a domain of $mathbb{R_{geq 0}}$:

• Clearly $lim_{x to 0^+} sqrt{x} = 0$. However $lim_{x to 0^-} sqrt{x}$ is not defined for negative numbers in this case, so $lim_{x to 0^-} sqrt{x}$ is undefined.


• If your course is on real analysis, they most likely assume that the domain is $mathbb{R_{geq 0}}$. However, this could depend very much on the context. If you are unsure what your course's convention is, you should consult a teaching assistant.


• In this case, $sqrt{x}$ is not continuous on $mathbb{R}$, since it is not even defined everywhere.

With a domain of $mathbb{R}$:

• As your plot shows you, both the real and the imaginary parts tend to 0, and so $sqrt{x}$ tends to 0.


• See above.


• Once again, your plot shows you that both the real and imaginary parts are continuous functions over $mathbb{R}$, and so $sqrt{x}$ is continuous over $mathbb{R}$.

Note that there is an even more general case, where the domain is $mathbb{C}$. This is where things get very strange.

There is undeniably a right-hand limit. You have $sqrt{x}to 0$ as $xdownarrow 0$. In fact, since $sqrt{0} = 0$, you know the square root function is right continuous at zero.

However, there is no possibility limit as $xto 0-$, since the domain of this function is $[0,infty)$. To discuss the left-hand limit of a function at a point $a$, the function must be defined in some interval $(q, a)$, where $q < a$.

The square root function is continuous on its domain. Since it is not defined on $(-infty, 0)$, it is often informally said that it has a "limit at zero."