How to solve $dot{x}=|x|$
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
How to solve this differential equation $dot{x}=|x|$?
differential-equations analysis
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
How to solve this differential equation $dot{x}=|x|$?
differential-equations analysis
@Rahul because initial condition is not given.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 11:10
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
up vote
1
down vote
favorite
How to solve this differential equation $dot{x}=|x|$?
differential-equations analysis
How to solve this differential equation $dot{x}=|x|$?
differential-equations analysis
differential-equations analysis
edited Nov 19 at 12:11
asked Nov 19 at 11:00
winston
419117
419117
@Rahul because initial condition is not given.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 11:10
add a comment |
@Rahul because initial condition is not given.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 11:10
@Rahul because initial condition is not given.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 11:10
@Rahul because initial condition is not given.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 11:10
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
One observes that $x=0$ is the trivial solution of the given ODE.
Now find nontrivial solutions of the equation.
Using separation of variables, one gets $$frac{dot{x}}{|x|}=1.$$
Integrating both sides gives
begin{align}text{sgn}(x)log|x|=t+Cquadcdotsquadtext{(a)}end{align} for some constant $C$, where $text{sgn}(x)=begin{cases}1,&x> 0\-1,&x<0.end{cases}$
Therefore, $x(t)=begin{cases}C_1e^t,&x>0\C_2e^{-t},&x<0.end{cases}$
Now find the solution of explicit form.
From the equation, $dot{x}$ is always nonnegative, so $x$ is a continuously differentiable and nondecreasing function of $t$. This shows that $C_1$ must be positive and $C_2$ must be negative.
Since $x$ is a continuous function of $t$ and a nontrivial solution of $x$ cannot take 0 by the above observation, it follows that $x(t)=C_1e^t,C_1>0$ for all $t$ or $x(t)=C_2e^{-t},C_2<0$ for all $t$.
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
bellcircle has provided a solution to the problem. However, I would like to express the solution in a more compact form and also provide an answer using a proposition-proof style.
$(Dx)(t) = |x(t)|$ (1)
Proposition. If $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$ and $C in mathbb{R}$, then $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on $I$. If $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$.
Suppose $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$. Suppose $C in mathbb{R}$ and $x$ is such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then $(Dx)(t)=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$. Also, $|x(t)|=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Therefore, indeed $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$.
Suppose there is a solution $x_2(t)$ of (1) on $I$ such that there is no $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x_2(t) = Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then take $T in I$. Define $A=frac{x_2(T)}{e^{mathsf{sgn}(x_2(T)) T}}$. Then $x(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$. The uniqueness of the solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$ follows from the Lipschitz continuity of $|cdot|$ by the Picard–Lindelöf theorem (link) and the global uniqueness theorem (e.g. link). Therefore $x_2(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ for all $t in I$ and, thus, by contradiction, if $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
One observes that $x=0$ is the trivial solution of the given ODE.
Now find nontrivial solutions of the equation.
Using separation of variables, one gets $$frac{dot{x}}{|x|}=1.$$
Integrating both sides gives
begin{align}text{sgn}(x)log|x|=t+Cquadcdotsquadtext{(a)}end{align} for some constant $C$, where $text{sgn}(x)=begin{cases}1,&x> 0\-1,&x<0.end{cases}$
Therefore, $x(t)=begin{cases}C_1e^t,&x>0\C_2e^{-t},&x<0.end{cases}$
Now find the solution of explicit form.
From the equation, $dot{x}$ is always nonnegative, so $x$ is a continuously differentiable and nondecreasing function of $t$. This shows that $C_1$ must be positive and $C_2$ must be negative.
Since $x$ is a continuous function of $t$ and a nontrivial solution of $x$ cannot take 0 by the above observation, it follows that $x(t)=C_1e^t,C_1>0$ for all $t$ or $x(t)=C_2e^{-t},C_2<0$ for all $t$.
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
One observes that $x=0$ is the trivial solution of the given ODE.
Now find nontrivial solutions of the equation.
Using separation of variables, one gets $$frac{dot{x}}{|x|}=1.$$
Integrating both sides gives
begin{align}text{sgn}(x)log|x|=t+Cquadcdotsquadtext{(a)}end{align} for some constant $C$, where $text{sgn}(x)=begin{cases}1,&x> 0\-1,&x<0.end{cases}$
Therefore, $x(t)=begin{cases}C_1e^t,&x>0\C_2e^{-t},&x<0.end{cases}$
Now find the solution of explicit form.
From the equation, $dot{x}$ is always nonnegative, so $x$ is a continuously differentiable and nondecreasing function of $t$. This shows that $C_1$ must be positive and $C_2$ must be negative.
Since $x$ is a continuous function of $t$ and a nontrivial solution of $x$ cannot take 0 by the above observation, it follows that $x(t)=C_1e^t,C_1>0$ for all $t$ or $x(t)=C_2e^{-t},C_2<0$ for all $t$.
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
One observes that $x=0$ is the trivial solution of the given ODE.
Now find nontrivial solutions of the equation.
Using separation of variables, one gets $$frac{dot{x}}{|x|}=1.$$
Integrating both sides gives
begin{align}text{sgn}(x)log|x|=t+Cquadcdotsquadtext{(a)}end{align} for some constant $C$, where $text{sgn}(x)=begin{cases}1,&x> 0\-1,&x<0.end{cases}$
Therefore, $x(t)=begin{cases}C_1e^t,&x>0\C_2e^{-t},&x<0.end{cases}$
Now find the solution of explicit form.
From the equation, $dot{x}$ is always nonnegative, so $x$ is a continuously differentiable and nondecreasing function of $t$. This shows that $C_1$ must be positive and $C_2$ must be negative.
Since $x$ is a continuous function of $t$ and a nontrivial solution of $x$ cannot take 0 by the above observation, it follows that $x(t)=C_1e^t,C_1>0$ for all $t$ or $x(t)=C_2e^{-t},C_2<0$ for all $t$.
One observes that $x=0$ is the trivial solution of the given ODE.
Now find nontrivial solutions of the equation.
Using separation of variables, one gets $$frac{dot{x}}{|x|}=1.$$
Integrating both sides gives
begin{align}text{sgn}(x)log|x|=t+Cquadcdotsquadtext{(a)}end{align} for some constant $C$, where $text{sgn}(x)=begin{cases}1,&x> 0\-1,&x<0.end{cases}$
Therefore, $x(t)=begin{cases}C_1e^t,&x>0\C_2e^{-t},&x<0.end{cases}$
Now find the solution of explicit form.
From the equation, $dot{x}$ is always nonnegative, so $x$ is a continuously differentiable and nondecreasing function of $t$. This shows that $C_1$ must be positive and $C_2$ must be negative.
Since $x$ is a continuous function of $t$ and a nontrivial solution of $x$ cannot take 0 by the above observation, it follows that $x(t)=C_1e^t,C_1>0$ for all $t$ or $x(t)=C_2e^{-t},C_2<0$ for all $t$.
edited Nov 19 at 13:25
Shashi
6,9591527
6,9591527
answered Nov 19 at 11:19
bellcircle
1,271411
1,271411
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
add a comment |
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
You first divided both sides by $|x|$ to get the following results. But how can you guarantee that you are not dividing by $0$. In other words, if you cannot guarantee that once the solution starts from a non-zero value, it will not reach $0$, then you cannot divide it by $|x|$.
– winston
Nov 19 at 12:30
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
@winston Good question. If $dot{x}=0$, then $x=0$ at such point. Now it is obvious that there is no way to combine the distinct (local) solutions $C_1e^t,C_2e^{-t},0$ to make a continuous global solution because the first is always positive, the second always negative, the last always zero. Therefore the global solution must be one of the three.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 12:47
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
bellcircle has provided a solution to the problem. However, I would like to express the solution in a more compact form and also provide an answer using a proposition-proof style.
$(Dx)(t) = |x(t)|$ (1)
Proposition. If $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$ and $C in mathbb{R}$, then $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on $I$. If $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$.
Suppose $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$. Suppose $C in mathbb{R}$ and $x$ is such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then $(Dx)(t)=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$. Also, $|x(t)|=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Therefore, indeed $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$.
Suppose there is a solution $x_2(t)$ of (1) on $I$ such that there is no $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x_2(t) = Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then take $T in I$. Define $A=frac{x_2(T)}{e^{mathsf{sgn}(x_2(T)) T}}$. Then $x(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$. The uniqueness of the solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$ follows from the Lipschitz continuity of $|cdot|$ by the Picard–Lindelöf theorem (link) and the global uniqueness theorem (e.g. link). Therefore $x_2(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ for all $t in I$ and, thus, by contradiction, if $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
bellcircle has provided a solution to the problem. However, I would like to express the solution in a more compact form and also provide an answer using a proposition-proof style.
$(Dx)(t) = |x(t)|$ (1)
Proposition. If $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$ and $C in mathbb{R}$, then $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on $I$. If $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$.
Suppose $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$. Suppose $C in mathbb{R}$ and $x$ is such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then $(Dx)(t)=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$. Also, $|x(t)|=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Therefore, indeed $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$.
Suppose there is a solution $x_2(t)$ of (1) on $I$ such that there is no $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x_2(t) = Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then take $T in I$. Define $A=frac{x_2(T)}{e^{mathsf{sgn}(x_2(T)) T}}$. Then $x(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$. The uniqueness of the solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$ follows from the Lipschitz continuity of $|cdot|$ by the Picard–Lindelöf theorem (link) and the global uniqueness theorem (e.g. link). Therefore $x_2(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ for all $t in I$ and, thus, by contradiction, if $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
bellcircle has provided a solution to the problem. However, I would like to express the solution in a more compact form and also provide an answer using a proposition-proof style.
$(Dx)(t) = |x(t)|$ (1)
Proposition. If $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$ and $C in mathbb{R}$, then $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on $I$. If $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$.
Suppose $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$. Suppose $C in mathbb{R}$ and $x$ is such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then $(Dx)(t)=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$. Also, $|x(t)|=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Therefore, indeed $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$.
Suppose there is a solution $x_2(t)$ of (1) on $I$ such that there is no $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x_2(t) = Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then take $T in I$. Define $A=frac{x_2(T)}{e^{mathsf{sgn}(x_2(T)) T}}$. Then $x(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$. The uniqueness of the solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$ follows from the Lipschitz continuity of $|cdot|$ by the Picard–Lindelöf theorem (link) and the global uniqueness theorem (e.g. link). Therefore $x_2(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ for all $t in I$ and, thus, by contradiction, if $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$
bellcircle has provided a solution to the problem. However, I would like to express the solution in a more compact form and also provide an answer using a proposition-proof style.
$(Dx)(t) = |x(t)|$ (1)
Proposition. If $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$ and $C in mathbb{R}$, then $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on $I$. If $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$.
Suppose $I$ is an open interval in $mathbb{R}$. Suppose $C in mathbb{R}$ and $x$ is such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then $(Dx)(t)=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$. Also, $|x(t)|=mathsf{sgn}(C)Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Therefore, indeed $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$.
Suppose there is a solution $x_2(t)$ of (1) on $I$ such that there is no $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x_2(t) = Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$. Then take $T in I$. Define $A=frac{x_2(T)}{e^{mathsf{sgn}(x_2(T)) T}}$. Then $x(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ is a solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$. The uniqueness of the solution of (1) on $I$ with $x(T)=x_2(T)$ follows from the Lipschitz continuity of $|cdot|$ by the Picard–Lindelöf theorem (link) and the global uniqueness theorem (e.g. link). Therefore $x_2(t) = A e^{mathsf{sgn}(A)t}$ for all $t in I$ and, thus, by contradiction, if $x(t)$ is a solution of the differential equation (1) on an open interval $I$ in $mathbb{R}$, then there exists $C in mathbb{R}$ such that $x(t)=Ce^{mathsf{sgn}(C) t}$ for all $t in I$
edited Nov 19 at 14:22
answered Nov 19 at 12:48
xanonec
16816
16816
add a comment |
add a comment |
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3004789%2fhow-to-solve-dotx-x%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
@Rahul because initial condition is not given.
– bellcircle
Nov 19 at 11:10